|
|
Deaths and Lifetimes
Passing Slowly |
|
|
The two pamphlets listed here, by Graham Clifford and
Alasdair Paterson, both come from award-winning poets: the former won the
Poetry Wales Purple Moose Prize 2010, whilst the latter won an Eric Gregory
Award way back in 1976, and has only recently returned to publishing his
work. |
|
|
The shadow of Ted Hughes falls across many of the poems in
Roy Davids's collection; he had a long-standing friendship with Hughes and
there are poems reflecting on that relationship and on the day of his
funeral. As Davids admits, this had a profound effect on him, and two other
long sequences 'Mother' and 'Father' were written in the shadow of major
heart operations in late 2006. There is, therefore, a large element of serious weighing-up and solipsistic
measuring of the self against others here, but the imagery can be powerful and
effective: he recalls schoolday agonies of going to 'the Dachau clothing
store/run by the Womens' Institute' and the angst of school visits by a poor
mother who cadges lifts home. My reservations stem from the over-use of the
first person and a feeling that confessional verse of this type has to be
rigorously shaped and pruned: 'Father', shaped by absence, seems, in this
respect, to observe distances that 'Mother' doesn't and to be more impressive
for it. Taken together, the two sequences create a fairly comprehensive
sketch of Davids's psychological scars, but I preferred some of the
stand-alone descriptive poems, well away from the psychodrama. A concluding
poem grudgingly admitting it was 'all right for Eliot' seems a final ironic
note, given what we now know about the psychological torment of Eliot's own
private life and first marriage. |
|
|
Alan Moore, in his second collection, How Now! also gives the reader the ingredients of his own
life - sometimes jauntily, as in '1973' ('Alvin Stardust beckons me with
driving-gloved hand'), sometimes with due seriousness, as in several poems
about his father's illness and death. In general, I found more light and
shade in Moore's poems than in Davids's and there is a fine cumulative
portrait of growing up in Ireland. 'Daddy', for example, ends with a list of
excuses: 'After I cut the grass./ After I wash my hands./ When we come home
from mass.' This concludes with an endless disappointed sense of deferral -
no further poetic 'wrapping up' is needed. The structure of the book takes
the reader through Moore's childhood, his early jobs and marriage, and
finally brings us up to now. There is a slight slackening of quality towards
the end, with several rambling sequences of impressions not quite cohering
into a poem, but the popular cultural detail rings true and sensory detail is
often vivid and convincing. It has been over twenty years since Moore's first
collection, Opia appeared: it
will be interesting to see what he makes of the disappointments and
challenges of middle-age, where the poetic raw material suddenly thins out. |